We met online through an app. Initially, we were friends and sexted, but over time we started talking about our daily lives, personal things, and basically everything. Eventually, he confessed that he had fallen in love with me and talked about how lucky he would be to have me as his life partner. After a few days, I accepted, and we became more serious.
We have never met in person yet.
At the beginning, he even unfollowed every girl from his following lists on all platforms. I’ve always had some trust issues with online relationships, but I genuinely tried to trust him.
The first incident
After around two months, I noticed he had started following a lot of girls again, and some of the accounts seemed suspicious. My instincts told me something was wrong, so I created a fake account myself and followed him.
He messaged the fake account very quickly.
He became friendly with the account and eventually proved it was really him by sending pictures and voice notes. He said he didn't have many friends to talk to, didn't have a girlfriend, and wanted someone to share things with. Eventually, he started bringing up sexting and said it was normal between friends because we don't live close to each other and there wouldn't be any feelings involved.
At that point, I confronted him.
He told me he had been influenced by his friends, that he thought the account might actually be me and that if it were me, I would agree. He also claimed that some of the conversations had been done by his friends. He apologized a lot and said he was genuinely sorry.
I was extremely emotional and attached to him, so I blocked him after the confrontation.
But eventually, we reconciled.
The second incident
After we got back together, I started noticing suspicious things from his side again.
This time, I found out that he had created another fake account on the same app and was talking to a girl.
The girl he was talking to is actually someone I know personally. She told me about the account and showed me what they had talked about.
The important part is that he doesn't know that I know this girl. So he has no idea that I found out about the account through her.
He also shared certain details with her that were things only I knew about him, which made me strongly suspect that it was actually him behind the account.
I haven't confronted him about this second incident.
And I haven't broken up with him either.
That's where I'm completely stuck.
The confusing part is that he isn't generally toxic or aggressive toward me. He's supportive, gentle, and calm. He talks about our future so naturally, says he wants me in every lifetime, and even asked whether he should tell his family about me. I told him it was too soon and that we should meet first and get to know each other properly.
He also started working part-time and told me he wanted to be able to do things for us himself. Whenever I get angry or emotional, he usually stays calm and listens rather than fighting with me. In many ways, he seems mature and serious about me.
What makes this even more confusing is how genuine he feels when we actually talk. When we're on calls, especially when we talk about our future, careers, things we want to do together, or even marriage, he sounds so natural and sincere. Those conversations don't feel forced to me at all. He seems genuinely excited about having a future together.
And that's what makes me question everything I've found out.
I keep thinking, if he's actually this serious about us, then why would he do these kinds of things? Why talk so seriously about our future and make plans with me, while also creating other accounts and talking to other girls?
Sometimes I start doubting every little thing I've found out. I wonder if I'm missing some explanation or misunderstanding something, because the person I experience on our calls feels so different from the person I see through these other accounts.
So in my head, I'm constantly stuck between two versions of him: the person who feels genuine, loving and serious about our future, and the person whose actions make me question whether I really know him at all.
And that's exactly why this is so difficult for me.
I know what most people are probably going to say: leave him, he's manipulating you, you're being stupid, have some self-respect, etc.
And maybe they're right.
But I'm not asking because I don't understand that his behavior is a huge red flag. I'm asking because I genuinely don't know how to leave someone I'm this emotionally attached to.
I'm scared I'll hurt him. I'm scared I'll regret it. I'm scared of being alone because he's become such a huge part of my life. And despite everything, there are so many moments where he is loving, supportive and makes me feel understood.
So what would you do in my situation?
How do you actually find the courage to leave someone when part of you still loves them and doesn't want to hurt them?
And should I confront him about the second fake account before leaving, especially since he doesn't know that I know the girl he was talking to? Or should I just leave without explaining everything?