r/LifeAdvice • u/DueWeek2161 • 18h ago
Relationship Advice Girlfriend wants to adopt children because of my allergies
I (34M) have been dating the most wonderful woman (F24) for nearly five years now and have been so fortunate to have almost zero relationship issues since the day I met her. We've talked about marriage and getting more serious recently, and my lady and I couldn't be more on the same page... until the topic of starting a future family together came up.
We've both made offhand comments and jokes about one day having children together, so I had always assumed it was a definite future plan. However, things got a little hostile during a conversation we had after her work party this weekend. I'll admit that we were both a little tipsy (she works for an accounting firm, so you know everyone was cutting loose at the event) so our words may have been more blunt than normal. Essentially, I made a half-joke about naming our hypothetical future son Jason (an homage our favorite SNL alumni Jason Sudeikis) and she responded that we might not get to name our child if we're adopting. I said something along the lines of "What do you mean adopt? Are you afraid of the pregnancy process and looking a little bloated for a few months?" (not my smoothest, I know) and she started to get choked up and told me she didn't want to talk about it until we got home. I then pried where I shouldn't have pried and she told me the truth.
Essentially, while she loves me more than the moon and back, she wants to adopt because of my genetics. I have a pretty awful set of allergies not limited to nuts, shellfish, citrus, pollen, gluten, etc. It's not the severity that is so bad, rather just the extensive list of things I cannot eat nor be in the same room as for safety. She's done an amazing job of being supportive towards this for our relationship (even gave up her childhood ritual of eating Snickers bars in bed on Saturday nights) but giving me a biological child is where she draws the line in the cement. I can understand her position, but it makes me feel hollow and achy inside when I reflect on what she wants here.
Lastly, I want to say I am by no means anti-adoption, I think we would make great parents (when we're ready in a year or two). I just always dreamed of having a biological son who shared my own physical features that I've grown to love about myself. I tried to smooth things over this morning by telling her that "if we have a kid with my DNA then we very well might have a professional kickboxer to support us when we grow old" but it just upset her more because she's never been much of an athlete/sports fan like me. I don't think it was the comment that upset her, more just the fact that she's stressed in general over this conversation.
I can clarify any particular questions you all might have, but I guess this is the part where I ask y'all for advice? I will do anything to get my way or reach a compromise. Breaking up is not an option because otherwise we are perfectly happy and always will be. This is just the hump on the camel's back that we have to get over.