I (26F) have been with my boyfriend, D (28M), since February 2022. My mom has wanted me to leave him for almost our entire relationship.
D did not exactly nail his first impression.
Early on, he was going through a difficult period with his mental health and taking prescribed medication. At a family picnic, he made the objectively stupid decision to drink several glasses of alcohol while taking it and became visibly impaired.
My mother immediately concluded: drugs.
He wasn't using drugs. I explained what happened, but it didn't matter. D had been tried, convicted and sentenced. As a lawyer, I'd like to note that the appeals process in my mother's court appears to be nonexistent.
I understood her concern. I'd have questions too.
The problem is that this happened in 2022.
It is now 2026.
And somehow, we're still at the picnic.
D and I continued dating and fell deeply in love. He's the person I want to tell things to and still the person I can picture annoying me when we're both ancient.
But our relationship never really got to exist normally.
My mother never literally forbade me from seeing him. I'm an adult, I work and earn my own money. Technically, I can do whatever I want.
Technically.
In reality, seeing D came with an emotional weather forecast. What mood is Mom in? When did I last see him? How long can I stay out? Is seeing him worth the atmosphere afterward?
Sometimes simply mentioning his name changes her demeanor.
After almost four years together, D had spent two nights with his girlfriend.
Two.
At this rate, by our 20th anniversary we might accumulate enough nights for a long weekend.
To be fair, my mother did not create every problem in our relationship. D and I had genuine issues. I felt taken for granted, some boundaries weren't respected, and I wasn't seeing enough change after we'd discussed things.
But the situation at home made everything harder. A misunderstanding that could have been resolved in an hour sometimes sat for days until it grew six additional heads and acquired a mortgage.
Eventually, I was exhausted from fighting problems inside my relationship while fighting for the relationship's right to exist outside it.
So earlier this year, I ended it.
Except we still loved each other.
Which was extremely inconvenient.
We spent months apart and tried moving on.
Before the breakup, we'd also started talking seriously about living together and even marriage. That terrified me, not because I couldn't imagine a life with him, but because I could.
What terrified me was imagining what I'd have to go through at home to actually have it.
I love my mother deeply. She isn't a monster. I genuinely believe she thinks she's protecting me.
There isn't an evil woman guarding the door yelling YOU SHALL NOT PASS.
I have a job, earn money and make serious decisions every day. Yet I come home and calculate whether having coffee with my boyfriend is worth making my mother unhappy.
I can make whatever choice I want, as long as I'm willing to pay for the "wrong" one with guilt and tension.
After years of that, nobody needs to stop you.
You start stopping yourself.
About two months ago, D and I finally sat down and had a long, calm conversation about everything that went wrong.
We talked about what had hurt each of us, acknowledged our own mistakes, and separated our relationship problems from the pressure surrounding it.
We decided to try again.
And these last two months have genuinely been wonderful.
Not everything-is-magically-fixed wonderful. Real wonderful. Calm, affectionate and fun.
We're communicating and resolving things. I'm seeing changes instead of just hearing promises, and I'm changing things too.
It's only been two months. I don't know what the next ten years will look like.
But my mother's position hasn't changed.
Recently D's name came up in an unrelated conversation. He wasn't there. Nothing had happened.
Just his name.
Her demeanor immediately changed. Coldness. Questions. Tension.
And I thought: Oh my God. We're still at the picnic.
Four years later.
Maybe D and I will last forever. Maybe we won't. Maybe someday everyone will tell me, "We told you so."
But isn't that my risk?
I'm 26. Shouldn't I be allowed to choose someone my mother wouldn't choose? Shouldn't I even be allowed to make a mistake without spending my life protecting her from the discomfort of watching me make it?
I don't want to choose D over my mother. I don't want it to be a competition.
I want to love them both without feeling like loving one means betraying the other.
Most of all, I don't want to wake up at 30 and realize I spent my twenties waiting for permission to live my own life.
I know my mother thinks she's protecting me. I know D gave her reasons for concern.
But I also know something she doesn't: what our relationship feels like when it's just the two of us.
Right now, I know what I want.
I want him. Not blindly, not at any cost, but I want the relationship we're building and the chance to find out where it goes.
AITA for staying with him?