r/preppers • u/rbprepin • 20h ago
Discussion Reranking the Best States to Homestead in the US
About a month ago I set out to answer the question, "What is the best place in the US for a prepper to move to if they want to homestead?"
I originally built my model around the basics: climate, water, food, security, cost of living and strategic distance. Unfortunately, my proxy for "food" was cropland, which incorrectly boosted places like Kansas and Iowa to the top of the list.
I've refined my ranking factors, and I would love your feedback on if you think this is the right.
- 17% Climate Stability - How hard natural hazards hit here and how far the temperature has moved from its 20th-century baseline.
- 17% Water - Whether water is here. Rainfall normals, or delivered irrigation.
- 17% Homestead Capacity - Whether a household on five to fifty acres could feed, heat and shelter itself here, and whether the law lets it. Forest cover for firewood and game, operations running one to nine head of cattle, growing season, and the state legal latitude over your own land: water doctrine, building-code adoption, food freedom and right-to-farm.
- 13% Social Stability - Net migration, social vulnerability, and crime rates.
- 10% Solar Potential - Annual solar irradiance.
- 7% Affordability - What it actually costs to live here: the annual cost of owning the median house (mortgage, property tax and homeowners insurance combined) alongside median rent. Lower cost areas score higher.
- 7% Privacy - Documented surveillance device density, the surveillance programs local agencies are recorded to run, exposure to the 100-mile border zone, and state legal protections.
- 7% Livability - Employment, primary care access, educational attainment, and household broadband.
- 7% Strategic Distance - Distance from publicly documented strategic sites and nuclear power stations, weighted by what each one is: ICBM launch facilities and command sites count for far more than a port or a refinery.
Overall Best States to Homestead
- Tennessee
- Alabama
- Missouri
- Maine
- Indiana
- Illinois
- Georgia
- Kentucky
- Vermont
- Kansas
Overall Best County to Homestead: (Carroll County, VA breakdown)
- Climate Stability - 67/100
- Water - 69/100
- Social Stability - 69/100
- Solar Potential - 33/100
- Homestead Capacity - 87/100
- Affordability - 86/100
- Privacy - 82/100
- Livability - 52/100
- Strategic Distance - 92/100
This list feels pretty much better to me.
Tenn. and the Ozarks are well represented. Maine surprised me a bit being so far north. West Virginia is pulled down from social instability and livability. Virginia has a lot of military targets and popular centers.
Would you say this list is accurate, or is something being overlooked?