r/PeterExplainsTheJoke 4d ago

Meme needing explanation Petah??

Post image
Upvotes

1.9k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

u/Ghostfish1309 4d ago

But it is a strategy. And since it isn’t even the best, according to you, why would anyone even be mad about it?

u/Muphrid15 4d ago

Some people seem to think any attempt to try to solve the game or play optimally (even if it's incorrect or flawed) is against the spirit of the game.

u/ScoutsOut389 4d ago

I just don’t understand that thinking. If the goal is to solve the puzzle, why not optimize for winning? Should I just throw a random 5 letter word out as my opener each time? JAZZY isn’t a great start.

u/Crazed_Chemist 4d ago

The individuals' answer is interesting, but unsatisfying. The "optimal" way to play requires the player know a list of options exists and using first picks based on said list. The vast majority of players might subconsciously know there is a list of options. They have absolutely no way of knowing what is on said list.

u/gmalivuk 3d ago

I doubt the list has changed much since the early days, when it was accessible through the page's source code. I suspect that version is still available in various places online.