I live in Wisconsin and deal with crazy weather changes. I see a lot of people say stay away from solid stains, but I've had zero luck with semi stains.
To provide some context of my issue, I have two decks, one it the front of my house and one in the back that are both 5 years old now. I had them stained using Pittsburgh Ultra semi stain and in one year, it started to look like it stripped itself. Very disappointed and thinking maybe someone else can do better, I had a professional come in and they stripped it, used deck brightner, and stain again in an oil based semi stain and they used Cabot. Looked great for about 1.5 years and they looks like crap again. Also looks like I have rot and have to replace some boards now.
I have a pool deck in my back yard exposed to more sun and also is exposed to chemicals for the pool and that deck is 20 years old. I've used solid grey stain from Ace hardware and I have stained it 3 times in 20 years. I just sold the pool a few months ago and they also removed the deck, there was little to no rot and still looks good with the last time I stained it being 5 years ago.
Many posts I read have people saying, "stay away from solid it will peel especially in climates with harsh winters." Well as I mentioned earlier I have had zero luck with semi stains and the solid stains seem to have more UV resistance and have lasted 5 plus years while semi stains seemingly have to be stained every 2 years max no matter how much prep.
Im thinking about going with solid oil based stain on my house decks since I had great luck with it on the pool deck and I get confused how people say semi is easier to maintain. I'm not looking to stain my deck yearly or every 2 years and it's a ton of prep to stain again while semi comes right off when and easily provides a consitant finish that is also easy to apply just using a thin coat or two. I understand solid just is more of a top layer while semi penetrates better, but anything I read online confirms that semi doesn't last as long and requires reapplications about every 1 to 2 years while solid it says every 3 to 5 years. Not sure why so many people are against solid and are for semi other than the look, which I agree, it is nice to see the natural grain and looks better, but I've had zero luck having it last.
Any suggestions? I just pressure washed my decks and I'm about to get them further prepped because I need to stain yet again this year.