I have two male cats, a 6 year old tuxedo named snape and a 1 year old black cat named Navali.
I live alone in a one bedroom apartment.
I got Navali when he was an only a few weeks old and has been rasied by Snape. He was a farrel that I picked up while working, has been to the vet and gotten his shots since. Not neutered, he’s not super aggressive or territorial so I was hoping I wouldn’t have to right now. For the most part he’s a really docile cat. He’s a hider and doesn’t like to show himself around people and is not curious about going outside. However as he gets older he’s starting to get more restless and playful. I’ve seen plenty of cats with more energy than him, he’s not a sprayer either, but he’s got a healthy appetite for playing around.
His increased energy is the problem in the cats relationship, but he’s not the problematic cat.
My other cat, Snape, is well…. A bitch. That’s the best way I can describe it. Once upon a time he was my sister’s cat. She picked him up via the cat distribution system like I did with Navali. He is neutered. He’s always been very choosy about who can be around and was her favorite. He lived in a 3 cat household with her up until about 3 years ago when she died. He was in the same room with her when it happened. I took him, her mom kept one and her friend took the other, it took 6 months of me laying beside him to even get him to come out from under my bed. He was confined to my room because I lived with my dad at the time and he had other cats. He got along with a senior cat of ours and the kittens we had fine. I had him for about a year before I got Navali. Snape likes to do this thing where he acts all big and bad when he’s got the upper hand, but can’t actually fight to save his life. He would tease one of our cats through the window, but get his ass kicked on the off time it was open.
I kept him separate nearly the whole time but he would always act like he was interested in making friends. There would be some progress, but ultimately he likes his alone time.
I got a kitten because I knew I was moving out soon and wanted him to have a friend/ have a cat of my own. Not just the one I inherited. They got along really well at first when Navali was a kitten, and Navali still adores Snape, but at one point Snape just snapped.
Now that Navali is older and getting closer to an adult size, snape does not tolerate them playing together anymore. It was like black and white, one day they were together all the time and cuddling, the next he wanted nothing to do with him. I think he’s intimidated now that Navali is big enough to win a fight. Now anytime Navali approaches him, he hisses and starts a fight where he’s screaming and fur is flying until he gets into a closed confined space where Navali can’t get near.
Navali always tries to approach snape and howls like “why won’t you talk to me anymore”. Sometimes he stalks and tries to do a playful swat but he never approaches with aggression. Snape is not very playful. Sometimes I get him to play but it’s not his favorite thing. I’ve made safe spots for him but so far he’s broken my bookshelf and two camps. He’s back to staying under the bed and they still fight each other every time they interact, it’s been months.
I separate them from time to time and play with Navali every day to get energy out of him. He sticks to me like glue when I’m home. When I hold snape I can bring him around Navali and hold them together, but not without an irritated look.
I’ve tried a couple things and it’s just getting worse. Now Snape is starting to poop under the bed because he can’t even make it to the two liter boxes right across the bed without feeling harassed. It smells awful and I’ve started sleeping on the couch when I’m too tired to lift my mattress and clean it every night.
I know I need to make more hiding spots and be more strict about separating them. They still can eat together although I have to move snapes food to the bed. Navali is admit about eating near him tho and I don’t always have the time to chase him down and pull him from under the bed to separate them before work.
I take snape out and let him in the living room while Navali is locked in the room like once or twice a week.
Snape has notably gained weight, but he does not overeat. He always gets the same one scoop of food and doesn’t always finish it. But that’s normal for him. He just isn’t moving around because he’d rather corner himself than interact with his brother.
Snape is very touch sensitive and gets overstimulated quickly. I’d rather not have to take him to a vet because I don’t have the money to blow on a bunch of tests and shit. But at this point maybe he needs something to manage his anxiety?
Navali is apart of the issue because he’s hopelessly persistent, but he’s trying mostly trying to be socialable and cuddle again.
I’ve been thinking about getting another kitten so that Navali has a companion to play with and take the pressure off snape, because he cries when he’s alone.
Now Im on the fence because I can’t imagine getting rid of either of my cats and adding a third that may make another problem that I get attached to doesn’t seem smart. I was just thinking that an actual hierarchy would make the situation better like when he was with my sister.
I’m at a loss of what to do. I don’t know how much longer I can tolerate my room smelling like shit and cats being at war when I work a full time job and am trying to go to college.
Any advice would be appreciated atp.