r/AmItheAsshole • u/Puzzleheaded_End2303 • 1h ago
AITA for telling my aunt I won't be doing the "kids table" seating at family dinners anymore now that I'm 26?
For as long as I can remember, my family has had a kids table at every holiday and big family dinner. Growing up it made sense there were like eight of us cousins and only one dining table that seats ten. As the older kids became adults, they'd graduate to the "adult table, usually once they hit their twenties or got married.
I'm 26. My cousin Tyler is 24 and got moved to the adult table last Thanksgiving because he got engaged. My cousin Chloe is 22, unmarried, and got moved up two years ago because she started working full-time and my aunt decided that counted. I'm 26, have had a full-time job since I was 23, own my own car, pay my own rent, and I'm still getting seated at a folding table in the den with the actual children, some of whom are under ten.
I brought this up gently to my mom a few months ago, kind of joking, and she laughed it off and said "oh you know how Aunt Denise is, don't make it a thing. So I let it go. Then at our Labor Day cookout last weekend, seating got assigned again, and I found myself at the kids' table between my seven-year-old nephew and a booster seat, while Chloe and Tyler sat at the adult table discussing mortgage rates.
I decided enough was enough. I quietly picked up my plate and sat down in an empty chair at the adult table instead. My Aunt Denise, who organizes seating every year like it's a wedding, noticed immediately and asked me, in front of everyone, to go back to where I was supposed to be sitting because the kids' table was short a chair without me. I said, calmly, that I'm 26 and I'd rather sit with people closer to my age, and that I didn't think that was an unreasonable thing to want.
She got visibly annoyed and said I was making a scene over a chair and that the seating has never been about age, it's about who's settled. I pointed out that Chloe is younger than me and unmarried and got moved up for having a job, which I've also had for three years. Denise didn't really have an answer for that, just said we'd talk about it later, which we did not do, because she spent the rest of the cookout being noticeably cold toward me.
My mom later told me I embarrassed Denise in front of everyone and that I should have just pulled her aside privately instead of switching seats in front of the whole family. My older cousin Ryan texted me afterward saying he thought it was funny and honestly overdue, but a few of my other relatives have been kind of quiet with me since.
I don't think wanting to sit with adults at 26 is some wild demand, but I also get that publicly relocating myself mid-dinner probably wasn't the smoothest way to handle it.
AITA?