r/StudioOne • u/Critical-Ask-2414 • 14h ago
What is the best way to "Punch in" record?
In punching in to overdub on a track, I like to hear the track playback until hitting the record button, at which time the track automatically (and immediately) turns on track input monitoring to hear the input source. In FSP, enabling "Audio track monitoring mutes playback (tape style)" does this with two unpleasant attributes:
1 When hitting record to punch in, the track begins recording immediately, but the monitoring takes a moment to activate and display as an active recording on the track. It would be better if the monitoring and display started immediately with recording. (It also turns on the monitoring in kind of a jarring manner, but I can understand that monitoring just comes on when it's turned on - I'm guessing this sense is from just expecting to hear the input immediately upon hitting record).
2 When the monitoring does activate, the blue track input monitor button does not turn on. Not a biggy as you can hear the monitoring but still would be nice to have the indicator show that input monitoring is turned on.
Am I missing something here or is this just how FSP operates? Is there a better way to do this basic punch in process in FSP providing immediate automatic input monitoring, track monitoring button indication and track recording display?
How do you accomplish "punch in" overdub recording?
I'm just seeking the most elegant and seamless way to punch in with FSP. Your thoughts, setup and procedures are appreciated!
Thanks in advance,
EDIT:
This appears related to low latency monitoring. When punching in with low latency processing engaged, FSP switches plugins - and track monitoring - to low latency (green) indication. The timing on this state change matches the monitoring lag when punching in. I have low latency processing and interface buffer size set to the shortest latency I can get out of my interface without artifacts, so it appears that turning off any active plugins while punching in will help minimalize the monitoring lag (Yes, I know, the more things the processor has to consider, the longer things take). I use X32 rack as my I/O and I know it isn't as speedy as better dedicated interfaces, but I need a LOT of inputs for the whole band, so for now I can live with the monitoring lag unless someone has some additional magic to consider here.

