r/RedDwarf 1d ago

Question/Discussion "Haven't you ever travelled interstellar?"

I've not sure how, but I only recently realised the implications of Todhunter's line in The End, where he is explaining stasis to Lister. He asks "Haven't you ever travelled interstellar?", which implies that ships capable of interstellar travel exist and are common enough that (Todhunter assumes) someone like Lister could have taken a return journey on one.
Even if the journey was still long enough to require staying in stasis, presumably these ships could still travel many light years in relatively short time, at close to or even exceeding light speed.

Until now, I'd always assumed the humans of the Dwarfiverse were confined to the solar system on slow moving ships and only the gelfs and droids and simulants had actually left (or been expelled).

Upvotes

53 comments sorted by

u/ImBonRurgundy 1d ago

This is exploring more detail in the book where lots of ships had been fitted with stasis drives for interstellar travel but then humanity relatively quickly realise that interstellar travel was totally pointless.

There was no aliens out there and when people got back to earth after years in stasis to find all their family continued aging their children were now older than them or even had died.

u/Marquar234 She'll never leave Fred and we know it. 1d ago

If there are no aliens, then who used all the bog roll?

u/Same_Ad494 1d ago

They probably do something weird and alienesque, like it comes out of the top of their heads or something.

u/yalkeryli Today's fish is Trout a la Crème. Enjoy your meal. 23h ago

I wouldn't like to sit behind one in a cinema.

u/CakeHoleKing 23h ago

Unless their poop is popcorn.

u/pattiemayonaze 22h ago

Hmmmm....I'm still saying no.

u/CatjoesCreed 14h ago

That's poopcorn, silly.

u/maciarc 23h ago

The Quagaars, with 2 A's.

u/MrScottBull 22h ago

And six breasts.

u/JDM2783 17h ago

Imagine making love to a women with six breasts 😲

u/MrScottBull 17h ago edited 17h ago

Imagine making love to a woman.

And I'm hoping that doesn't classify as a self-burn since I'm quoting Red Dwarf.

You could always ask my girlfriend except she's got a puncture.

Smeg...

u/Badger-of-Briarwood 23h ago

It's a smegging garbage pod!

u/Street-Frame1575 1d ago

A fact the greeting card companies took full advantage of...

u/Cornelius-B33 23h ago

I'd forgotten that bit in the books. I haven't read them in about 30 years.

Presumably interstellar travel is still common enough at the time for Todhunter to consider it possible that Lister might have done so.
I suppose the novelty had wore off for most of the human race before the time of the Nova 5, although the fact that that ship and it's new drive were even developed shows someone had a interest in going that far. Even if it was only advertising agencies.

u/Street-Frame1575 21h ago

The book explained that when they cracked interstellar travel mankind went off to explore every inch of the galaxy, hoping to find intelligent life. When they didn't even find an intelligent plant (or even a stupid plant), the stasis booths were reassigned as a punishment option.

The Nova 5 didn't travel interstellar though, instead it had a Duality Drive, essentially exploiting quantum uncertainty to "choose" where in space to be.

It'd take a long time though to get back to Earth when Lister re-emerged from stasis. Kryten estimated that it could take 2, possibly 3 months...

u/ESCF1F2F3F4F3F2F1ESC 21h ago

That passage in the first book about the stasis booths is so wonderfully bleak, especially the way they frame it with Rimmer using them to waste his life every evening by very slowly adding only about a year to his overall lifespan.

I love those first two books. A pair of films based on them with a darker/bleaker tone than the series (and with a different cast, obviously) might work really well one day.

u/Street-Frame1575 21h ago

"Although his birth certificate said he'd be 31, he was actually only 30. Pretty am-smeggin-azing eh?"

Then "Rimmer intended to spend the last evening of his life not existing"

Beautifully, darkly, perfectly written for Rimmer

I totally agree re the reboot - can't wait for it!

u/Technical_Scallion_2 18h ago

The funny thing is, I got the first book and loved it without realizing it was based on a TV show. Then a few years later I was channel flipping and came across Legion and saw the big H on a Rimmer’s head, and I was like “cool! They made a Red Dwarf TV show from that book!”

u/CaptConstantine 11h ago

The section about the months on end where Lister would stagger into the control room naked and drunk at 3AM to scream at Holly gives me chills.

u/ESCF1F2F3F4F3F2F1ESC 10h ago

Yeah that's always stuck in my mind as well! That and the BTL arm-carving

u/Consistent_Blood6467 20h ago

But that suggests two things also happen when using the stasis booths.

Either, it gives you the benefit of a full night's sleep, or-

You don't get the equivalent of any sleep in it at all, and go about the next day as tired as you were before going in the booth.

Now Lister doesn't look tired either before or after he goes into the booth, and we never see anyone else go into the booth or coming out of them, as far as I can remember, so we've no proof that it does either. But if going into it while tired still leaves you tired and Rimmers been using them instead of sleeping, that might explain a bit about his behaviour - coupled with everything else we do know of his past.

u/ESCF1F2F3F4F3F2F1ESC 20h ago

I might be misremembering but it's actually bleaker than that, he doesn't use them instead of sleeping. He uses them instead of socialising or doing anything else with his spare time in the evening. Then he goes to bed.

u/Consistent_Blood6467 19h ago

Damn, that is bleaker...

u/ESCF1F2F3F4F3F2F1ESC 10h ago

Honestly those two first books are fantastic, they're full of stuff like this. They add so much to the characters.

And what they do with the Better Than Life premise is genius. That part is a genuinely unsettling bit of sci-fi horror.

u/ImBonRurgundy 19h ago

No, you have it exactly correct. Rimmer is such a paethic person this perfectly encapsulates his personality imho

u/Consistent_Blood6467 19h ago

Just on the matter of how much life Rimmer might have "saved," assuming he's had a full 8 hours every night for a full year, that's 2920 hours he's "saved." A full year has 8760 hours, so he must have been doing this for awhile to save a full year of life. Maybe three years of this process to save a full year?

Let's say Rimmer had managed to do this over the full run of a JMC career, and that was 40 years like the real world merchant navy apparently is (and rechecking the Google results is giving me different, contradictory details all the time). A full 40ish year career doing this from the ages of 16-55 would save him 116,800 hours... That's about 13 years.

Which is an unlucky number...

And if Grant Naylor had done the maths to figure that out, it would be a very apt number, given Rimmer's horrid luck.

But, Rimmer's ID post-retirement would say he was 55, but he'd really be more like 42...

Oh dear god... did they just get a really subtle Hitchhiker's Guide reference in?

(Google searches intensifies, and gets more of the contradictory information re the Merchant Navy which kills the idea, but what the hell?)

Well, quickly looking things up, probably not. Apparently Rimmer joined at 17. And since Google has decided to give me totally different information compared to my original searches, there is no mandatory retirement age for the MN, but a typical career is apparently up to 40 years, while joining is typically around 18, but 16-year-olds are still accepted.

u/TonksMoriarty 8h ago

Don't trust Gemini output. It's completely unreliable.

u/mornnx1 Better dead than smeg! 4h ago

The Nova 5 did travel interstellar they had to find the right type of star in the right galactic cluster for the coke ad. We see in the book that Rimmer is sent to check out the engine half of the crashed N5 and finds the stasis booths the crew members inside dead and the hologram crewman stuck in a loop. The crew took the journey there and back in shifts six months on six months off in stasis.

u/Street-Frame1575 4h ago

Yeah sorry my bad.

I was trying to explain the Nova 5 didn't need Stasis Booths to travel vast distances as they used the Duality Drive, but of course they could still travel interstellar regardless of method (I think I mixed up "interstellar" with "FTL" in my head yesterday).

Anyway, after all this chat you can guarantee I'm not even thinking of drinking Pepsi.

u/Technical_Scallion_2 18h ago

It’s just a bunch of smegging rocks from what I hear.

u/PeterJamesUK Kill Crazy 21h ago

Exactly. The 5 closest stars to us are between 4 and 7 light years away, a round trip at the speed of light (if lgnoring acceleration and deceleration, which is where the real time is taken up, would have to take between 8 and 14 years, ignoring the time spent there. In reality it's probably double that with the acceleration and deceleration.

u/Relevant-Bullfrog215 17h ago

For the outside observer. For the traveller it could be arbitrarily quick depending on how many 9s you want to put at the end of 0.9999..c. You could reach Andromeda within a human lifetime.

u/Pyrkie 15h ago

I saw something recently that basically says if you accelerate (and then decelerate) constantly at 1g, you can be anywhere in the universe in about 30 years, because the time dilation becomes exponential. Just you need a system that lets you accelerate at 1g constantly (and the fuel) and the 30 years is just from your own point of view…

Also much of the universe is already unreachable because of the accelerating expansion… so Andromeda is about as far as we can get.

u/Relevant-Bullfrog215 9h ago

I mean two whole galaxies is plenty to be getting on with

u/tmofee 1d ago

If you pay careful attention to the latest series, it’s hinted that they’re in the outer limits of explored space by now. They’re picking up automated robot television.

I always assumed that like they say in the books the space fleet stretched out their hands, discovered that they’re the only living creatures in the universe and just gave up. Why bother colonising deep space when there’s nothing else out there?

u/cosaboladh 20h ago

Why bother colonising deep space when there's nothing else out there?

To be the something else out there. Big picture, earth—if properly cared for—can only give us 4 billion or so more years. After that, the sun is going to start boiling off our atmosphere, and oceans.

Now bear in mind that humans don't take good care of earth, and will probably never learn to. It makes sense to build supply chains between mineral rich systems, and systems with habitable planets. To extend our reach, and ensure the perpetuation of the human race. The universe is so vast, we could destroy every planet we live on until the heat death of the universe, and never run out of new places to ruin.

u/TonksMoriarty 8h ago

*1 billion. Earth becomes too hot for life in 1 billion years as Sol's luminosity increases as it ages.

u/CrazyMike419 1d ago

Our nearest stars are 4 to 6 light years away. That's doable with stasis. That said... Wasn't kryten found on a ship called "nova 5". A ship that was out there causing supernovas to create a coke advert?

Seems very clear that interstellar travel was a thing "in universe"

u/Grizzl0ck 1d ago

Kryten was built in like 2340, about 150 years after the Red Dwarf started barreling it's way out of the solar system. The Nova 5 had jump drive technology far in advance of what was avaialable at that time.

u/rnh21 23h ago

Yeah, but so did the Albanian State Washing Machine Company

u/ThePeaceDoctot The Riviera Kid 23h ago

He was, but he wasn't built until approximately 150 years after the accident.

u/dave_lister169 1d ago

It's hard being alone.

u/Revolutionary-Key650 1d ago

It's just hard mate.

u/maciarc 23h ago

More or less.

u/MrScottBull 17h ago

You're not alone...there's always Rachel; just get out the puncture repair kit and we won't judge you.

Though I've been seeing her behind your back.

u/salty-sigmar 23h ago

In the book interstellar travel is explained as having been done using stasis, but largely abandoned due to the seeming emptiness of space. It also says that the returning travellers often struggled to fit back in to society having arrived home long after the deaths of their own grandchildren.

We could make up some headcanon then that Todhunter might actually be one of those early interstellar astros and on paper is hundreds of years old, having left earth in stasis centuries ago and returned recently before taking on a fresh commission of red dwarf. Maybe it's not uncommon in space corp to meet someone born two centuries ago who was part of those early stasis based missions and is still working through their contract as SC doesn't count time in stasis as time worked. It'd make sense that an early astro would choose to stay in space since everyone they knew back on earth is long gone.

u/Evening-Tomatillo-47 22h ago

It's just occurred to me that some of them still wouldn't get back for a really long time. In fact could some still be out there 3 million years later?

u/salty-sigmar 6h ago

Maybe thats another of the subtle tragedies of red dwarf - for all we know there might be a booming human civilisation somewhere out at the edges of space, but the chances of lister and co stumbling upon it are beyond miniscule.

u/Cornelius-B33 5h ago

And of course somewhere presumably there's the crew that abandoned ship at the end of Series 8, or maybe their descendants.

u/Werthead 21h ago

The worldbuilding and continuity of the franchise has always been fairly nominal, but yes, the idea in the OG series is that interstellar travel via stasis booths was fully possible, just not routinely done.

In later seasons Kryten notes that FTL travel is possible, and they indeed use it themselves with the matter paddle and then see it in action with the holoship Enlightenment's tachyon drive. Not to mention the time wand that not only moves them back and forth in time, but also transports them to Earth at the time of Jesus (why they didn't use it to go back to the Solar system a week after the nuclear accident is waaah I've gone crosseyed).

u/Tight-Awareness-5114 22h ago

I partly attribute that to class difference. Someone like Lister would be unlikely to travel interstellar but Todhunter doesn't realise that.

u/Kooky-Giraffe-2415 21h ago

Damn! How great would it be to see someone create a Red Dwarf interstellar mini series!! I'd love that now!! 😋😋🚀

u/2612chip 1d ago

This is a good catch!