William Holden's Lime Gelatine with Carrots, Olives and Nuts from the 1949 booklet called "What Cooks in Hollywood". Like I said, I was curious. These types of Jello salads were all the rage back in the 40's, 50's and 60's, so I picked this one to try since I had everything to make it except the Lime Jello.
Mr. Holden says that he first tried this at Glenn Ford's place, so now we have 2 old-time celebs connected to this recipe, and he goes on to say it's his favorite!
So I bought the Lime Jello and from there it wasn't hard to make.
- I made the Jello according to the package and added the lemon juice in with the cold water.
- Now it was put in the fridge to set up for a couple of hours until it thicken just a little.
- Half the recipe- While it was sitting in the fridge I put together the other ingredients. I only was going to put these savory things in 1/2 the Jello and save 1/2 the Jello plain for my family to eat.
- So I added 1/2 cup of grated carrots, 1/4 cup of whole cashews and about 6 large green olives with pimientos, sliced into a small bowl and waited until the Jello was slightly thickened.
- When ready, I reserved 1/2 of it and then used the other half mixed in with the Carrots, Olives and Nuts. I used 2 small silicone molds (small cake/large cupcake size) to mold this concoction.
- Put it all back in the fridge over night.
- It unmolded easily and now you can see how it looks! It's almost like a green aquarium with little sea creatures floating inside. So I did as "Bill" suggests added a bit of mayo and a sprinkling of paprika, two of the mid-century's most favorite ways to finish a dish. (Yes this is green mayo. It was left over from another dish I made yesterday, and I'll be sharing it soon)
- With this hot weather we've been having, this seemed like a great time to try this. And yes, It does jiggle nicely!
So the taste, or rather the texture is interesting. The Lime Jello with the carrots and cashews is surprisingly good and fun to eat, but when you get to the olives, yikes! It's a mouthful. Maybe I should have chopped them smaller, because you get this big hit of olive that's really strong. Definitely chop them up if you're making this. I'm going to try it again later when my husband gets home and remove the olives and chop them up and see if there's a difference. Not sure there will be!
My family never served things like this growing up. Well, they're Italian and from Argentina, so this kind of food fare wasn't on their radar, luckily. It was all about cheese, salami, lettuce, and veggies for salads with us. My husband on the other hand remembers his grandparents making and serving things like this, so I'm curious to get his opinion on the taste.
Until then, if you're not familiar with William Holden, I highly recommend 2 of my all-time favorite movies:
- Sabrina - I love him playing the carefree, rich playboy chasing after Audrey Hepburn and dealing with his brother Humphrey Bogart.
- Sunset Boulevard - Then he completely flips the script and plays this broke, cynical screenwriter who ends up face-down in a swimming pool after getting tangled up with a delusional old movie star, played by Gloria Swanson.
William Holden absolutely crushed it in the early '50s with two of director Billy Wilder's absolute masterpieces. It's wild seeing him go from a desperate Hollywood hustler to a smooth-talking flirt, but his natural charm made both look completely effortless.
Some recommendations include affiliate links