r/india 7d ago

Scheduled Ask India Thread

Upvotes

Welcome to r/India's Ask India Thread.

If you have any queries about life in India (or life as Indians), this is the thread for you.

Please keep in mind the following rules:

  • Top level comments are reserved for queries.
  • No political posts.
  • Relationship queries belong in /r/RelationshipIndia.
  • Please try to search the internet before asking for help. Sometimes the answer is just an internet search away. :)

Older Threads


r/india 7d ago

Scheduled Mental & Emotional Health Support Thread

Upvotes

Welcome to /r/India's mental and emotional health support thread.

If you are struggling and are looking for support, please use this thread to discuss your issues with other members of /r/India.

Please keep in point the following rules:

  • Be kind. Harsh language and rudeness will not be tolerated in these threads. The aim is to support and help, not demotivate and abuse.
  • Top level comments are reserved for those seeking advice.

Older Threads


r/india 4h ago

Non Political As a mother, I have lost all hope in India after the Satya Niketan PG collapse

Upvotes

The Satya Niketan PG collapse has shaken me in a way I did not expect.

Seven people died. Young people, students. our demographic dividend.

What scared me even more was looking at the buildings around it. Tiny plots, four-five-six floors squeezed on top of each other, questionable construction, but a nice coat of paint, lights, a decent-looking facade and from outside, you assume it must be safe.

But how is a normal person supposed to know?

How are parents and students supposed to know whether the foundation is strong enough, whether the building was legally extended, whether the structure was inspected properly, or whether somebody simply paid someone to look the other way?

We have no choice but to trust the owner, the engineer, the authorities.

And I think that is the trust I have lost.

Earlier, I used to blame politicians. But now I realise it is much deeper than that. Politicians, government officials, builders, business owners- the entire chain. These areas and these buildings have existed through multiple governments and multiple political parties. Everybody has seen them. Everybody has allowed them to continue.

Just a few months ago, 23 people died in the fire at Flourish Stay near Saket. Many were foreign nationals who had come here around medical treatment. There were reports of major fire-safety violations and rooms being squeezed into the property.

There was outrage. Then silence. And how many similar buildings are still operating today?

This is what has made me lose hope.

In India, basic safety often feels like Russian roulette. You leave your house and you don’t know whether it will be an open manhole, a hanging electrical wire, a speeding thar, a road cave-in, a building collapse, a fire exit that doesn’t exist, or flooding that leaves schoolchildren stuck in buses for hours.

Yes, accidents happen in other countries too. I know that.

But here, preventable danger feels so widespread that we have almost normalised it. Chalta hai. Jugaad hai. Kuch nahi hoga.

Until somebody dies.

I am 38. My parents are getting older. My life is here. I cannot simply uproot everything and move abroad now.

But my son is still small.

I will work, save and sacrifice whatever I reasonably can so that when he reaches university age, he does not have to study or build his life in India

Maybe India becomes much better by then. I genuinely hope it does.

Maybe he studies abroad and comes back. Maybe he chooses India himself.

But I want it to be his choice.

Because as a mother, I can teach him road safety, choose his school, make him wear a seatbelt and try to protect him in a hundred ways.

But I cannot inspect every building he enters, every bridge he crosses, every electrical wire on the road, or every fire exit.

At some point, a parent has to be able to trust the society around their child.

Right now, I don’t.


r/india 13h ago

Religion Eiffel Tower workers go on strike after female staff 'sidelined' for Hindu group's visit

Thumbnail
france24.com
Upvotes

r/india 2h ago

Crime Canada Police release photos of Indians charged in extortion cases | Chandigarh News

Thumbnail
indianexpress.com
Upvotes

r/india 1h ago

Health 22M Diagnosed with Lymphoma Stage 3S. Confused and Worried

Upvotes

22M had cervical nodes for 2-3 years, very weird clinical history + dismissive behavior of doctors condition remain undiagnosed. Now finally with the help of a good pathologist after biopsy + ihc + later pet I have been diagnosed with classic stage 3 hogdkin lymphoma.
Now here is the thing, when the pathologist suspected lymphoma he referred us to Delhi State Cancer Institute where around 1.5 months of time was wasted with zero productivity they couldn't reach a diagnosis everything was super slow, whereas when we reached back to the pathologist with our problem it took us just 15 more days to get the diagnosis.
Here is the thing the diagnosis + biopsy was done in Ujala and father trusts them now and that is where he wants to get the treatment done.
When i did some research I found out that for stage 3 cHL Nivo-AVD is that standard most successful approach. Also luckily there is a indian biosimilar Tishtha which is only 1/4 the cost. The question is where should I get the treatment, I am worried what is the during transportation the chain is broken, and the chemical is not longer effective. I know it might be a little stupid but I genuinely don't want to die for nothing. Is in general transportation of these substances to even tier 2-3 towns considered reliable?
Where can i get reliable treatment in india, if possible north side? anyone else who has experience with cHL and Nivo-AVD treatment in india let me know. Thanks a lot :)

Also as a side note, around 1.5 years ago, i was given linezolid and clinmacydin for 1.5 months, during this the node sizes went down significantly, though some nodes still remained, immediately after the treatment stopped the nodes increased in size, so possibly not coincidental waxing and waning as typically seen in cHL. Is this weird? could this be infection + cHL, I will mention this to my onco in next meeting. Also the progression has been slow? as in the nodes have persisted for around 2 years now. No type B symptoms


r/india 11h ago

Law & Courts ‘Orwellian dystopia’: Allahabad HC blasts Noida DM over DU student's NSA detention during Noida workers protest

Thumbnail
newindianexpress.com
Upvotes

r/india 12h ago

Law & Courts Student Activist Sues Sudhir Chaudhary Over Allegedly Defamatory News Broadcast During CJP Protest

Thumbnail
livelaw.in
Upvotes

r/india 11h ago

Politics Youth has done its part. Now, Opposition must act - Raghuram Rajan | The Indian Express

Thumbnail
indianexpress.com
Upvotes

r/india 6h ago

Environment Mumbai could be swallowed by the sea. BMC begins a fresh risk check

Thumbnail
indianexpress.com
Upvotes

r/india 20h ago

Foreign Relations Singapore sees wave of anti-Indian posts amid Nepal floods, PM's office steps in

Thumbnail
indiatoday.in
Upvotes

r/india 2h ago

Law & Courts Night entry, lifting clothes don't amount to rape bid: Jharkhand HC

Thumbnail
timesofindia.indiatimes.com
Upvotes

r/india 16h ago

Crime Indian Woman Arrested for Running Telegram Porn Network: Sold Videos of Minors for as Little as $1

Thumbnail
techtimes.co.uk
Upvotes

r/india 11h ago

Politics Padma Shri Awardee Harekala Hajabba Gets SIR Notice Over Name Discrepancy

Thumbnail
ndtv.com
Upvotes

r/india 15h ago

Politics Ambulance stuck in pothole for 2 hours, unborn baby dies in Agra

Thumbnail
timesofindia.indiatimes.com
Upvotes

r/india 14h ago

Politics Donations to six Gujarat-based parties exceeded those to national parties except BJP, reports BBC

Thumbnail
scroll.in
Upvotes

r/india 19h ago

Politics Rahul slams govt over Delhi PG collapse, says PM slaps labels like 'naraaz phoopha' on those who ask questions

Thumbnail
newindianexpress.com
Upvotes

r/india 15m ago

Religion If ISKCON is taking over someone you love, please read this before it’s too late.

Upvotes

If someone you love is becoming deeply involved in ISKCON, please read this before you dismiss the red flags.

I have spent roughly 20 years living with the consequences of ISKCON inside my family.

I wasn’t an ISKCON devotee, but I was the child who had to live with one.

My mother found ISKCON when she was at one of the most vulnerable points in her life. She was struggling with depression and desperately looking for hope and meaning. My maternal uncle was already a very serious ISKCON devotee and eventually became a sannyasi, giving up ordinary family life to dedicate himself to the movement.

My mother followed him. At first, I think ISKCON genuinely gave her something she needed. Hope and a community- A reason for her to keep going.

But over the years, that spiritual practice became increasingly rigid. And eventually, the entire family had to live according to it.

I was around 12–15 years old when it became a major part of my life.
I was forced to follow Ekadashi fasting.
I was made to feel guilty for eating onion and garlic because they were considered spiritually impure/sinful.
Normal teenage things like watching movies, TV, going shopping, eating food from friends box (who were non iskcon folks), etc, became religious issues.
The message was increasingly that ordinary pleasure was Maya, something pulling you away from Krishna.

And when you’re at an impressionable age, you don’t have the intellectual freedom to distinguish between “this is my mother’s religious belief” and “this is objectively how the universe works.”

You just follow the person you trust. I did the same - followed whatever my mom insisted during my early teens.

But as I grew older, when I was in college, I started questioning. I had stronger opinions as I started doing my own research on who is god, and how do we connect with the god, etc.

And that’s where I think things become dangerous. The more I dug deeper and asked questions, the more arguments I had with my mother.

The more she forced me into iskcon in the name of guilt, I started observing some really BAD, glaring things that ISKCON openly presents till date:

1. The “us vs. them” mentality
ISKCON’s theology places Krishna as the Supreme Personality of Godhead and describes other Hindu deities such as Shiva, Durga and Muruga as subordinate beings/demigods.
That’s not merely a philosophical distinction when it is imposed on a family. It can make other Hindu traditions appear inferior or spiritually misguided.
For a religion that comes from the incredibly diverse ecosystem of Sanatana Dharma, I find this exclusivity deeply troubling.

2. “Bhagavad Gita As It Is” becomes THE TRUE GITA
One of the most damaging things I experienced was the absolute confidence with which Prabhupada’s interpretation was treated as the authentic meaning of the Bhagavad Gita.

The Gita has been interpreted by numerous Hindu philosophical traditions for centuries. But questioning Prabhupada’s interpretation within my family was almost equivalent to questioning spiritual truth itself. ISKCON heavily privileges bhakti yoga while other approaches such as jnana and karma yoga are often subordinated to its devotional framework. And Prabhupada didn’t exactly demonstrate intellectual generosity toward competing spiritual teachers.

He made extremely harsh remarks about other spiritual leaders like Ramakrishna Paramahamsa and Swami Vivekananda, calling them “rascals.” Why if you ask- simply because of their non-dualist (Advaita Vedanta) teachings and for practices like worshiping material energies or Kali instead of pure Krishna bhakti.

If your spiritual teacher’s interpretation is the only legitimate one, and everyone outside it is misguided, what happens to independent thinking?

3. Prabhupada’s controversial statements
Prabhupada and his disciples teaching on the role of women and men and how they should lead an ideal family life is extremely regressive!! Not just women, remarks regarding race and various historical figures that are extremely uncomfortable.
When questions are being asked, the devotees simply defend saying the meaning of their teachings are misunderstood.
A spiritual leader should not become so sacred that his followers feel compelled to defend everything he ever said.

4. The fear and guilt around ordinary human life
This was probably one of the biggest things I witnessed.
Sex outside the specific purpose of procreation is considered sinful.
Meat is sinful. Onion and garlic are sinful.
Material enjoyment and worldly attachment or success is Maya.
Even enjoying ordinary things can be framed as spiritual deviation.
And then comes karma and rebirth which is completely based on the varna caste system. Their theory is as humans we accumulate sinful reactions and those sinful reactions affect our next birth.

That is, if you are a Brahmin and continue to do sinful activities, you will be reborn into a shudra family. And if you are a shudra in this birth, but do lots of good deeds, you will be reborn as a Brahman in next birth.

Think about what that does psychologically to a vulnerable person. You aren’t simply making choices anymore.

You’re constantly wondering:
“Am I accumulating sin?”

That is an incredibly powerful mechanism of control when someone has been taught to fear the consequences beyond this lifetime. And imagine the kind of trauma this induces for children who attend Gita classes by ISKCON.

5. The varna/caste hierarchy
Like I mentioned above, the way ISKCON discusses varna is another thing I find deeply disturbing. The traditional hierarchy places Brahmins above other varnas, with Shudras occupying a serving role.

And the karmic framework can associate one’s actions in this life with one’s circumstances in future births. Whatever philosophical explanation is given for this, I find the idea of humans being placed into a hierarchy of spiritual/social worth profoundly problematic.

Especially when such ideas are taught as divine truth rather than something open to critical examination.

6. Aggressive preaching
I’ve personally witnessed devotees approach people outside traditional, non-ISKCON Hindu temples to preach Krishna’s supremacy. And worst of all, they collect donation saying, contribute for a bigger cause or contribute to get more punya.

Imagine going to worship Shiva, Muruga or Durga and being told that the deity you worship is essentially a demigod and that Krishna is actually supreme. That’s not how I understand Hindu pluralism. It feels like religious competition masquerading as spiritual outreach.

And god!!! These people have insane marketing strategies to collect high donations. They know whom to target and at what time. They attack people who are vulnerable, people who go the temple seeking some comfort, people who are depressed. Rather than helping, they target them and gradually lure them into this mess in the name of devotion.

7. The guru worship is deeply disturbing
This is probably the part I find most cult-like.
I have personally seen devotees collect sand from the path their guru walked on.
I’ve seen devotees perform abhishekam/pada puja to their gurus when they visit their homes and then consume the water as something spiritually purifying.
I’ve seen people eat the remnants of food left by their gurus.

And my mother has personally forced me to participate in these practices because I was told that doing so would bless me.

I cannot understand why a human spiritual teacher should be elevated to that level. Respecting a teacher is one thing. Treating a human being’s footsteps, bodily contact and leftovers as objects of spiritual purification is something else entirely.
And when questioning the guru becomes spiritually dangerous in the believer’s mind, that is when reverence can turn into submission.

8. And ultimately, the family pays the price
This is the part people don’t talk about enough.
My father eventually became deeply involved too. Initially, my mother pushed him toward ISKCON. Eventually he followed it, and from what I witnessed, part of that was simply to maintain peace in their marriage.

And I was the child caught between them.
I didn’t choose this path no matter how much they forced me to. And believe me when I say, my mom did everything she could to make me follow iskcon. I MEAN EVERYTHING!!!!!!

But I stood my ground very very strong even though it has been an emotionally draining process. And over time, it destroyed my relationship with them. Today, at 30 years of age, I have made peace with the fact that my parents have chosen this lifestyle.

I no longer try to change them or argue with them about every theological contradiction. I’ve accepted that this is their life. And I have strictly asked them to not involve me in their ISKCON lifestyle as I have a family of my own now. In the end, the only way I have been able to preserve my own sanity is by maintaining distance from my parents. And that is heartbreaking.

Note:
So when I say “ISKCON is cult-like,” I’m not saying every devotee is a bad person.

I’m saying that I have personally experienced a system where:
questioning is discouraged and often countered with extreme defensive responses.
one interpretation is treated as absolute truth and any sort of deviation creates fear and guilt,
gurus are placed on extraordinary pedestals,
other religious traditions can be portrayed as inferior, and the beliefs of one devotee can end up controlling an entire family.

If your parent, partner, sibling or loved one is showing these patterns, please don’t immediately dismiss them as “just becoming spiritual.

Look closer!!!
Are they becoming more compassionate and open-minded? Or more fearful, rigid and judgmental?
Are they developing their own understanding or becoming incapable of questioning their guru?
Are they respecting your choices? Or demanding that you live according to their beliefs?
Are they becoming closer to their family? Or increasingly withdrawing from everyone who doesn’t share their worldview?

Please pay attention to the difference. Because I spent almost 20 years learning it the hard way.
And if you’re a child of deeply involved ISKCON devotees and you’re reading this thinking, “Holy shit, this is my family” you’re not crazy.

You don’t have to hate your parents or this lifestyle. You don’t even have to convince them they’re wrong.

Sometimes, saving yourself means accepting that you cannot save them and creating enough distance to finally breathe.


r/india 15h ago

Crime Manipuri musician dies after delivery boys, dhaba staff assault him in Delhi; all accused held

Thumbnail hindustantimes.com
Upvotes

r/india 22h ago

Politics West Bengal BJP President Says Anyone Calling BJP's Practices 'Ganda Dharma' Will be Eliminated

Thumbnail
thewire.in
Upvotes

r/india 21h ago

History Freedom fighter born in 1950? Coaching institute book mentions PM Modi among prominent personalities, netizens slam 'history pe jumla'

Thumbnail
deccanherald.com
Upvotes

r/india 23h ago

Politics To tackle dengue, Bengal minister asks girls to swap skirts for salwars in schools - India Today

Thumbnail
indiatoday.in
Upvotes

r/india 1d ago

Politics Call to keep Durga Pujas in West Bengal vegetarian kicks up a storm

Thumbnail
thehindu.com
Upvotes

r/india 16h ago

Law & Courts 'Despotic' Officers Will Turn UP Into 'Orwellian Dystopia' : Allahabad High Court Slams Noida DM For NSA Detention Of Student

Thumbnail
livelaw.in
Upvotes

r/india 1d ago

Foreign Relations UP engineer detained in Moscow, pressured to join Russian military, claims wife

Thumbnail
indiatoday.in
Upvotes