r/CPC Ontario Jul 01 '26

📰 News Durham MP’s Canada Day address draws scrutiny for inflammatory rhetoric and factual gaps

https://provincialtimes.ca/durham-mps-canada-day-address-draws-scrutiny-for-inflammatory-rhetoric-and-factual-gaps/
Upvotes

18 comments sorted by

u/Reasonable-Sweet9320 Jul 01 '26

“But the address quickly pivots to a litany of grievances, from flag protocol to immigration enforcement and foreign aid, framing them as threats to a Canadian identity he says is under systematic attack.

The most jarring moment comes midway through, when Jivani takes issue with prayers from “another religion” being heard in Regina's public square.The reference to the Muslim call to prayer, which Saskatchewan's capital has hosted at city hall during Ramadan in recent years—sits awkwardly beside his opening praise for Canada as a nation founded on religious freedom.”

Critics of the line have pointed out that the public expression of minority faiths is not an erosion of tolerance, but a direct exercise of it. Jivani offered no explanation for why the presence of those prayers would constitute a threat to Canadian values.”

A focus on divisive and polarizing topics especially on Canada Day is unfortunate. Jivani talking points are the same as Tommy Robinson and Nigel Farage in the UK and the same as JD Vance and hundreds of other MAGA politicians in the United States.

The CPC is a very different party at its core than the Progressive Conservative parties that remain, for now, in Canada.

u/RoddRoward Jul 02 '26

Pointing out the absurdity of muslim call to prayers is not divisive. Pretending like its not a big deal is cowardice. 

u/blonde_discus Jul 02 '26

As far as I know, only the Christian’s (of which I am one) do door to door trying to convert people.

Now that I’m on their no-solicitation list, they mail me regularly.

So which religion is more of a threat to one’s way of life? The one that peacefully prays, minding their own business; or the one that hounds you like a used car salesman.

The same tolerance that the first Christians were coming to the Americas in search of, is what we should be giving to new comers now.

Keep our country secular as it should remain but let them have the same freedoms.

u/ludicrous780 Jul 02 '26

The Muslim prayer quite loud, and goes on for a while. I'm fron Mumbai so I know how it goes.

u/blonde_discus Jul 02 '26

Church bells are also quite loud and can go on for a while.

Regardless, it’s not divisive or an assault on our national identity.

u/K0bra_Ka1 Jul 02 '26

It's not a big deal. No different than church bells.

Everyone has the right to express their religious beliefs free from threats or harm under S.2 of the Charter. Denying a call to prayer is absolutely an infringement.

u/ludicrous780 Jul 02 '26

Nope.

It's quite annoying, and long. I've heard both.

u/K0bra_Ka1 Jul 02 '26

The permit was for 3 minutes at noon. I think you'll survive my dude.

u/ludicrous780 Jul 02 '26

You don't know how loud it is.

I do because I'm from Mumbai.

u/K0bra_Ka1 Jul 02 '26

So only Mumbai has a call to prayer? Pretty bold of you to assume where I have lived and worked in my life my dude.

I can promise you that I have heard a Mosque broadcast a call to prayer before and I wasn't triggered becuase I'm not fragile.

u/ludicrous780 Jul 02 '26

Who says I'm fragile?

u/K0bra_Ka1 Jul 02 '26

You're crying about a three minute call to prayer in the middle of the day...

u/kryptos99 NDP Jul 02 '26

There’s more to identity than ethnicity, language, or religion.

u/No_Mention8589 Jul 02 '26

This has to be the most wedgiest wedge issue I have ever seen. Will any Canadian think of this issue and say wow I better vote for the conservative to stop this.

How about focus on crime, immigration, or cost of living.

u/K0bra_Ka1 Jul 02 '26

Especially when they applied for and received a permit for a three minute call to prayer at noon. People lost their shit and uttered threats of violence.

This is absolutely disgusting and embarrassing behavior. Especially since the people outraged the most were crying about their own personal freedoms less than five years ago.

u/No_Mention8589 Jul 02 '26

Thankfully this is only Jamil Jivani saying this shit. He is known for associating with JD Vance and MAGA, which unfortunately lumps the whole party with the MAGA movement in some people’s eyes.

If Harper was still leader, Jivani would have been reprimanded heavily.

u/K0bra_Ka1 Jul 02 '26

This isn't the first time he has done his own thing. Either Scheer or Poilievre need to accept responsibility for members of their caucus runing rogue and embarrassing the party as a whole.

u/RoddRoward Jul 02 '26

Liberals still pushing hard for that "post national state with no core identity." They almost have it.