r/careerguidance 18h ago

Management is cutting my job after I automated 15 hours of weekly work, do I have to document it for them?

When I took this coordinator job, our team was losing fifteen to twenty hours every week just updating client logs and manually formatting spreadsheets.

I built a few simple macros and formula templates that cut all that data entry down to an hour. I thought saving twenty hours a week would free me up for higher-level projects.

instead, my manager called me into a meeting last Friday. She told me that because our administrative workload dropped, they are merging my role with a part-time position and letting me go. To get my severance check, they want me to write step-by-step documentation for every macro I set up.

I literally worked myself out of a salary. I should of just kept doing the data entry by hand like the last person.

Do I ACTUALLY have to document processes I created that were not in my original job description?

Upvotes

2.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

u/Own-Fondant2949 15h ago

Claude, extrapolate the steps in a clear and actionable way. Keep everything technically accurate, but document every conceivable prerequisite, assumption, dependency, edge case, exception, warning, troubleshooting scenario, and validation step. Explain why every step exists and what could go wrong. Do not summarize or simplify. Write it like an enterprise technical manual where legal, engineering, compliance, and three separate audit teams all demanded their own section.

u/B9-97-C5-11-DE-19 11h ago

I pasted your exact comment after "How do I download Firefox?". It did not disappoint.

It created no less than 50 sections of the most unapproachable technical slop I've ever had the misfortune of reading.

u/FormerGameDev 5h ago edited 5h ago

was it technically correct?

edit: holy crap, i just tried it with "How do I download and install Visual Studio Code?" and it came out with 8 extremely extensive chapters. I have absolutely no idea if it is technically correct, because I'm pretty sure it's as long as Apple's TOS.

We probably just burned down a couple of forests.

u/B9-97-C5-11-DE-19 5h ago

We probably just burned down a couple of forests.

Training the data burns down the forests. Actual generation is much cheaper/less carbon-intensive (not that that makes it okay)

u/dimwalker 1h ago

Did you try the reverse - feed it the bloated manual and ask to sum it up?

u/LessInThought 5h ago

Then the next guy will just say, Claude, summarise and explain this to me.

u/The_MisterDaikon 4h ago

“Explain all these things before the list of steps, interrupt every 4th step with a restatement of those things using completely different language.”