r/monarchism 7d ago

Blog Norway: Funeral Service for Late King Harald V

Thumbnail
youtube.com
Upvotes

r/monarchism 2d ago

Weekly Discussion CXXII Has the UK effectively crossed the line from a constitutional into a ceremonial monarchy?

Thumbnail
gallery
Upvotes

I ask this question because I feel that, despite formally being a constitutional monarchy, I am of the opinion that the UK (and most so called “constitutional” monarchies) are really, de facto ceremonial monarchies.

Compare say George III to Charles III. Both are constitutional monarchs, yet, George III held significant power and influence over the government, and Charles III does not.

George III actively exercised all the authority granted to him in British constitutional law. He actively appointed and dismissed ministers, utilised royal patronage, and exercised royal prerogative at his discretion. He has a real influence over day to day government and politics of his day. The Whigs threw a few tantrums at this, but George III nonetheless acted well within British constitutional law.

Charles III technically holds all the same powers, but he exercises none of it by his own accord. It is done by ministers on his behalf. When he does act it is again, on the advice of ministers. The easiest example is dissolving Parliament, which he retains the formal authority to do, but it is only done at the PMs request.

I would argue the switch really happened in the reign of Queen Victoria. William IV was the last to attempt to dismiss a government and failed to do so. From there on, the British Crown was heavily constrained by convention till today. Obviously, things had been moving in this direction since, the “Glorious” Revolution (some argue it was the English Civil War but I do not believe so, Charles II possessed all the traditional prerogatives his father did, dissolved Parliament at numerous times during his reign, and for the last 4 years of his reign ruled without it entirely). But the switch from a constitutional to a ceremonial monarchy happened in 1834.

A constitutional monarchy, I would say, is one where the monarch is constrained by constitutional law, and exercised his authority in accordance with it. The UK today still fits this de jure, but, I would argue, de facto, it has slipped into what is effectively a ceremonial monarchy.

Please do tell me what you think of this.


r/monarchism 3h ago

Passing of Queen Elizabeth II 8th September 2022: HM The Queen Elizabeth II of United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland died at the age of 96. Her reign of 70 years and 214 days is the longest of any British monarch and was the first monarch to die in Scotland since James V in 1542.

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

Upvotes

r/monarchism 2h ago

History TIL: Dom Pedro II the Emperor of Brazil appeared in an anime

Post image
Upvotes

Today I Learned: Dom Pedro II the Emperor of Brazil appeared in an anime

Anime: Time Travel Shoujo: Mari Waka to 8-nin no Kagakusha-tachi (also known as Time Travel Girl).

Episodes: Episodes 8 and 9, which focus on the life and inventions of Alexander Graham Bell.

Context: The episodes accurately portray the real-life historical connection between Dom Pedro II and Graham Bell. The Emperor of Brazil visits Bell's school for deaf students, marvels at his work, and later helps champion telephone technology and Bell's inventions internationally.

Clarification: I used the History flair because of the time travel theme of the anime.


r/monarchism 2h ago

Photo Accession Day 2026. In a time of political turmoil, the seamless succession that Monarchy provides is more important than ever.

Thumbnail
gallery
Upvotes

r/monarchism 7h ago

Question Whats this light blue sash many Bourbon monarchs seem to wear? Sorry if its a stupid question

Post image
Upvotes

I read somewhere that it is a reference to the Order of the Holy Spirit, which was awarded by the king of France before the Revolution.


r/monarchism 3h ago

In Memoriam Some Photos Shared by the Norwegian Royal Family of King Harald V Being His Lovely Self

Thumbnail gallery
Upvotes

r/monarchism 3h ago

Question Question about regnal numbers

Upvotes

Mods, please remove if this breaks the rules (I read them and don’t think it does but apologies if so).

I have tried to research this scenario but I keep drawing blanks… 

I have a fictional country, let’s call it Doggerland (it’s a well trodden trope but let’s run with it). In its early days it was independent and had its own kings. Three of them were called ‘Erik’ so their regnal numbers are of course Erik I, Erik II, and Erik III.

But then it’s conquered by Denmark. Denmark then, per reality, has 8 Eriks of its own (before all the Christians and Frederiks).

Question: If these Eriks were kings of Denmark and Doggerland, would Erik I of Denmark also be Erik IV of Doggerland? And, if Doggerland later became independent of Denmark and then had a new King Erik, does he become Erik XI (3 Doggerland Eriks plus 8 Danish Eriks)?

Thank you for any help. I realise this is a strange question!


r/monarchism 19h ago

History Feliz 7 de setembro!

Post image
Upvotes

On this day, Pedro I waged war against the masonic Courts of Portugal. The emperor compared himself as Aeneas, the greek hero whose fate was to give birth to an empire!


r/monarchism 1d ago

News A new life-size bronze statue of Queen Elizabeth II

Post image
Upvotes

A new life-size bronze statue of Queen Elizabeth II has been unveiled outside Romsey Abbey in Hampshire, four years in the making since the project began around the time of her Platinum Jubilee.

The unveiling was carried out by Hampshire Lord Lieutenant Nigel Atkinson and the Countess Mountbatten of Burma, with the Lord Lieutenant describing the late Queen as a "constant presence" whose 70 year reign was defined by "duty and quiet strength."

Sculptor Amy Goodman, who has strong personal ties to the town, having married there in 2019, said she drew inspiration from the Queen's coronation regalia at Windsor Castle, hand carving every detail of the outfit herself.

Goodman described the statue as a "sister queen" to another of her Elizabeth II works, deliberately designed with the robe falling over the opposite shoulder to create a subtle visual connection between the two pieces.

The project also involved extensive community engagement, with local residents and schoolchildren contributing ideas and artwork throughout its development.

This comes from FB: All About Great Britain.


r/monarchism 18h ago

History Happy 204th Independence Day, for the Empire of Brazil

Thumbnail
gallery
Upvotes

r/monarchism 19h ago

Question Which monarchies have succession crisis besides Japan right now?

Upvotes

Meaning there’s a lack of heirs to the throne, not necessarily no heirs.


r/monarchism 1d ago

Discussion Every President Blood Related to Evil King

Post image
Upvotes

r/monarchism 1d ago

Genealogy House of Capet - All male line descendants from Hugh Capet until today

Thumbnail gallery
Upvotes

r/monarchism 1d ago

News Crown Prince Reza Pahlavi's immediate response to the gad price hike: The regime forces the people to bear the price of its incompetence

Thumbnail gallery
Upvotes

r/monarchism 1d ago

Discussion What is your opinion of the java island's monarchies?

Post image
Upvotes

opinion on the Java monarchies


r/monarchism 1d ago

Question After Peter the Great established the law of succession, Russian Tsars could designate anyone they chose to succeed to the throne, so why did they not establish a harem?

Upvotes

Why Russian Tsars do not have harem?

The Tsar could choose to have his illegitimate son inherit the throne.

Seeking advice on plausibly incorporating a Chinese-style harem setting into a novel with a Tsarist Russian cultural backdrop.

I specify "Chinese-style" rather than "Ottoman-style" because concubines in the Chinese harem were often of noble birth, unlike their Ottoman counterparts, who were all slave women.

Furthermore, a Chinese monarch could have only one queen or empress; a concubine's son could succeed to the throne only if the queen had no son. The titles and status of the queen's children were superior to those of the concubines' children—a practice more akin to European culture.


r/monarchism 1d ago

Question is true that Prince Carl Phillip was offered Estonia throne as king ?

Post image
Upvotes

i know Prince Edward rumored was offered by Estonia for throne in 1991 and i heard sources that people of Estonia want Carl Phillip as their king.


r/monarchism 1d ago

History Muhammad Reza Shah talking about the needs of the Iranian people in the future Iran

Thumbnail
vt.tiktok.com
Upvotes

He was truly a patriot who really cared about his nation/country with all his heart.


r/monarchism 2d ago

Question Why Does So Much of the World Hate the Monarchy?

Post image
Upvotes

I don’t understand why so much of the world hates the monarchy. I understand that it can be criticized, but people often focus only on the negative aspects and overlook its historical and cultural importance, as well as the functions it still serves in some countries. For example, in the United Kingdom, the Crown has representative, ceremonial, and diplomatic functions. I also think it is often overlooked that, for many people, the monarchy is part of their country’s identity and traditions.


r/monarchism 1d ago

Blog New Zealand: Te Arikinui Kuiini Nga wai hono i te po

Thumbnail
gallery
Upvotes

The annual address by Queen Nga Wai Hono i te Po reaffirms the Kingitanga’s enduring commitment to Maaori empowerment, respectful engagement with Pacific leadership, and constructive partnership with Aotearoa-NZ's institutions including government and community organisations.

Courtesy : Kingiitanga | Instagram - Above in english translation of speech


r/monarchism 2d ago

Meme Another Jacobite Classic

Post image
Upvotes

r/monarchism 2d ago

Photo A poster of king George I of Greece ready to be crowned as Emperor by Constantine XI of the byzantine empire

Post image
Upvotes

r/monarchism 2d ago

Photo Happy 20th birthday, Prince Hisahito

Post image
Upvotes

r/monarchism 2d ago

Discussion Argentina’s monarchy flag

Post image
Upvotes

recommendations? we are also constructing a coat of arms, if u know someone or are willing to help our project message me!