Being a couple years distanced from it now, I feel like I have a much less nostalgic view of my fraternity experience than many here. I wanted to share my thoughts and see if others have felt this way because I was a bit melancholic reminiscing about this.
Now, there are a number of factors involved in this, not all of which are necessarily the org's fault. COVID definitely wrecked my freshman/sophomore year, so only being able to really get into it in person junior/senior year was probably bad. I was also at a very highly ranked (~Top 25 globally) institution where academics were the forefront and Greek Life was not the focus, basically the polar opposite of a large SEC school. During Halloween etc., I'd actually go to another school across town because their decorations and theming were much more legit.
I had a stint as Pledge Master and suggested some really cool initiatives like funding for a couple bids each cycle that had waived dues for students from low income backgrounds, which I am genuinely proud of. We were always in the top couple houses on GreekRank. I came from a highly conservative, strict upbringing so Greek life to me was a way to experience everything I'd missed out on growing up.
I bought in fully to the refrains about brotherhood, lifelong connections, being with people wanting to achieve at the highest level possible in all aspects of life (personal, professional, social). After rushing I started to get the first hints that it wasn't all it was cracked up to be. Again, this is, I'm sure, very heavily dependent on chapter and org so I will try not to make generalizations, but when I thought of fraternities I thought of great men, business magnates, policymakers, titans of academia and art being members.
I began to realize my ostensible brothers were… just typical frat guys. Fun to have a drink with? Absolutely. Will I remember one of them backflipping off the house roof at a party forever? Probably. But beyond partying and a perfunctory obligation to philanthropy and other programming, it felt like these men did not really strive for much. I wanted to be amongst the best of the best and leaders of the next generation.
Furthermore, and I realize this is my personal factor, I enjoyed the levity of partying but realized that the general promiscuous nature of relationships between frats and sororities was just not for me. The fact that at formals a given girl probably had been intimate with a nonzero number of my brothers was just not compatible with my internal philosophy. I realize playing fast and loose with relations is integral to typical Greek behavior but I guess it's not something I knew about myself until I was actually in the situation. But college is for figuring these things out, I guess.
All this to say, I was looking at my DMs with former brothers and it's been a year since I've talked to the guy I was closest with, who now works at a sushi spot. I'm just on a totally different life trajectory from the people I used to spend so much time with. This past month, one of the top three American newspapers published an interview with me about my career and rapid ascent. I do not say this to be elitist or flex, but rather am melancholic that I don't feel like these guys ever got the drive, ambition, and standards for excellence that I hold for myself, or understood why.
And that seems like the polar opposite with how most people here look back on their Greek days.