r/AskReddit 12h ago

Gym bros, what sacred knowledge of getting Gains do you swear by and will always recommend?

Upvotes

2.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

u/wegnbealrght 12h ago

If u wannna get strong as fuck you gotta EAT!!!!!

u/BadDub 11h ago

Honestly i thought eating would be easy, but when i calculated my protein intake vs what I need I was only getting half. The thought of eating more doesn’t sound appealing

u/mrdreka 11h ago

That is why most people take protein shake, easy and cheap way to hit your protein needs.

u/joric6 8h ago

It's not cheap anymore though. I saw 5lb tubs for $100 on Amazon yesterday, those used to cost 50-60

u/katzenschrecke 7h ago

Even at Costco they went up 50%

u/erix84 6h ago

I think I paid $70 for a "5lb" bag of Gold Standard at Costco.

My bag weighed almost 6lbs. Weighed it after seeing a bunch of videos of that guy that was weighing stuff at Walmart and Kroger and everything was under weight.

u/Key-Cry-8570 5h ago

Gold Standard Whey is the best.

u/Supercocoquentieux 2h ago

My brother in christ straight up spittong FACTS (rip)

u/Many-Use-1797 55m ago

I remember being in college and grasping at 5lb ISO for $45. They now want $120+ for the same.

u/kakaluski 2h ago

It is still cheap if you just switch away from whey to milk protein or casein or anything else.

u/BadDub 11h ago

How many scoops do you do in a day?

u/ToosterReeth 11h ago

As many as you need to hit your protein goal, that's the only answer that ever matters

Or if you're generally curious about others, I usually have 2-3 (or about 75g)

u/icedearth665 10h ago

If you need to have 75g of protein coming from whey you should reevaluate your diet

u/trixtah 7h ago

If you just made that comment in a fitness thread then you should reevaluate your lack of knowledge next time you try and chime in

u/Outrageous_Jelly_131 9h ago

You don't know his weight nor his goals nor his lifestyle. People always be making comments like this when talking about gym/diets when they don't know shit about the why, and even then that's a totally normal amount for bodybuilding purposes

u/I-was-a-twat 7h ago

You try hitting 250g without smashing the protein shakes.

Also whey isn’t the only protein base available these days.

u/That_Apathetic_Man 4h ago

Eddie Hall over here, giving us advice on macro's.

u/socokid 4h ago

Until just a few months ago, the federal RDA of dietary protein for adults was 0.8 grams per kilogram of body weight. For a 150-pound adult, that’s around 55 grams of protein a day, or the equivalent of an 8-ounce steak. The newly revised dietary guidelines instead recommend 1.2 to 1.6 grams per kilogram, raising that 150-pound person’s recommendation to 80 to 110 grams a day.

https://med.stanford.edu/news/insights/2026/03/how-much-protein.html

You straight up have zero idea of what you speak. You should delete your post.

u/ToosterReeth 53m ago

I'm 6'4 so yes I need a higher than average protein amount and this fits my lifestyle, but thanks for your concern uninformed stranger

u/_bk_adv 11h ago

It’s gonna depend on the type of protein and brand.

But I used do take mass gainer back in the day. It was about 1400 calories with 4 scoops and water. I would use whole milk instead, throw in some peanut butter, some banana and some other fruits. Ended up being around 2100 calories and I would drink it right before bed.

u/dgjapc 10h ago

Serious question, how were your shits?

u/_bk_adv 10h ago

Had to take a fiber supplement. I developed an impaction once and that was absolutely brutal dealing with. Imagine trying to shit out brick of poo the size of a softball.

u/dgjapc 10h ago

No, I don’t think I will.

u/Droctagon316x 10h ago

Ok well imagine a large lego brick like a house brick size then

u/Mobile_Throway 4h ago

Too late. We all know you did.

u/MaxxDash 3h ago

Do it

u/PhoenixRisen95 3h ago

happened to me when i was a kid. bevause i didnt drink enough water. i will never forget that.

u/eightslipsandagully 10h ago

The problem with a lot of mass gainers is they maltodextrin as a bulk source of calories/carbs

u/dgjapc 9h ago

I recently learned maltodextrin has a glycemic index that’s nearly twice that of table sugar. Many processed food manufacturers will sneak it into their sugar-free products, but it’s absolutely terrible for blood sugar. Diabetics beware.

u/eightslipsandagully 4h ago

I'm not diabetic but I noticed I was getting the worst rush and crashes after drinking it. Decided to just eat more instead lol

u/Imnotveryfunatpartys 7h ago

Well hey, insulin is an anabolic hormone

u/dgjapc 7h ago

Two sides to every coin, right?

u/Mobile_Throway 4h ago

Which is great. As long as you're sensitive to it.

u/_bk_adv 10h ago

Probably. I haven’t taken any in years. I don’t think the brand I used is even made anymore. MusclePharm.

u/nleachdev 9h ago

Did you have to force it down and go to bed bloated? My biggest issue is if I want to smash a two scoop shake, I either take 30+ min to finish, or force it down quicker than 30 min and feel bloated as fuck

u/_bk_adv 6h ago

I originally was forcing it, then I gave up. Eventually I just started drinking half at night and finishing the other half after breakfast.

u/fugazzzzi 4h ago

Eating 2100 calories right before bed? Your digestions slows down during sleep. Wouldn't that cause indigestion, disruption of sleep, heartburn, and cause you to get fat?

u/johnny-faux 10h ago

blend up a 1,000 calorie shake with 80 grams of protein. makes every thing so much easier!

i blend up bananas, berries, greek yogurt, cottage cheese, oats, peanut butter, chia seeds and protein powder

u/workoutnerd 10h ago

This is the way. I like the chia seed add, might use that.

u/Manhattan_24 10h ago

I use the Ryse cinnamon toast cereal one. If you use two scoops and three cups of the Fairlife lactose/fat free, it's like, almost 90G of protein and like 650 calories.

u/Nick_pj 8h ago

Focus on grams of protein in the shake, not scoops. 

u/butsuon 8h ago

Depends a lot on how big you are or how big you're trying to be.

Sometimes, the answer is "yes" many scoops.

u/KYLE_FREELAND 7h ago

Adding on here: add egg whites!

My home shake includes two scoops of whey isolate, 4 oz egg whites, and 8 oz fairlife whole milk. It is disgusting, but it packs ~80g of protein and ~400cals

u/BorelandsBeard 6h ago

Yogurt is really good too.

u/Kr4k4J4Ck 5h ago

cheap

Yea maybe 3 years ago lol

u/kurafuto 11h ago

You probably need less protein than you think, and with even lower youre still going to make progress, it just wont be maximal. 0.6-0.8g per lb, and if you're fat (a lot of beginners probably are) its even less. Concistency matters more.

u/zyh0 9h ago

For the overweight folks, go by height in cm for protein. I'm 6'1 which is 185.4 cm, so 0.7 of that is about 130g of protein. 

u/lepsek9 6h ago

Back in "my day", the golden rule was 1g/kg of bodyweight, so about 0.5g/lbs.

Chicken and eggs are a blank canvas, don't be afraid to use spices and sauces. Same for your carbs. Unless you are prepping for a comp, you are gonna be fiine with those few extra calories,

Eat your veggies too! A lot of people sneer at them, eww empty calories and whatnot, but they taste soo good when prepped properly and can mix things up a lot! Make a meat heavy curry with some chickpea, carrot and roccoli, or a stir fry, or chicken noodle soup with a bunch of chicken. Meatloaf and meatballs are great, you can afford a bit of tomato sauce! Egg salad wraps? amazing!

For the love of all the holy gains, don't have to live on plain chicken and rice!!

u/cefriano 3h ago

To add on the veggies: vitamins are essential for building muscle too (and just… being alive). Don’t get so focused on protein that you forget all the other things that make up nutrition.

u/TotallyNotAnIdiot478 3h ago

Really? Shit, I've only been hitting 50-75% of my protein needs? Is that a 'real' ratio? Or one that fits the thread?

u/Big_Special29 2h ago

You can go lower but 0.7g per lb of bodyweight maxes out your gains. If you are in a caloric deficit or an elite lifter going up to 1g per lb can be worth it.

u/TotallyNotAnIdiot478 2h ago

lol I've been on a ~1400 calorie/day diet for a couple months. Making a push for the next, maybe final, 10 pounds. Finally hit the weight goal(175), but dang I'd love for a couple hundred more calorie wriggle room.

I'm just scared to 'ruin' my weight progress.

u/Big_Special29 1h ago

That's a big deficit and not eating enough protein will have probably cost you some muscle mass.

However the general health advantages of getting to a healthy weight far outweigh the disadvantages of losing some muscle imo. 

Are you currently doing or planning on doing strength training? In that case I'd suggest you try to get your protein intake up to 0.5-0.7g per lb if you can. Will be a lot easier once you can start eating more ofcourse.

u/Polymoosery 9h ago

Who knew eating could be so exhausting?

u/Chaetomius 8h ago

Professional body builders get made fun of for eating seasonless chicken and rice. But they gotta take in so much, they don't want to risk getting sick of some flavor. They just gotta get the chore over with.

u/the_jowo 8h ago

No one's ever gotten fat eating chicken and rice

u/06_TBSS 8h ago

When I first started working out in my 20's, I was 6'3" and 145lbs. I ate a lot as it was. I just had a high metabolism and was constantly moving. I had to eat 5-6k calories per day before I saw any meaningful gains and it took a long time to not just feel miserable all the time. I had to force food down my throat every 2 hours and I hated it. It eventually paid off, but good lord.

u/AntonVice 11h ago

Egg whites in the morning, protein shake/greek yogurt in the afternoon, chicken breast in the evening. Fuck ton of protein right there. There’s many ways you can hit that goal though. Once you figure out what works for you it becomes a breeze.

u/wegnbealrght 10h ago

It is hard at first but after a while its pretty easy especially when you add protein powder although i wouldnt rely only on protein powder try to eat every meal you eat that has a high protein source like chicken or ground beef/turkey

u/baldymcbaldyface 10h ago

Protein shakes taste like ass to me. I’ve been upping my protein intake with Pure Protein bars. 20g of protein for around 200 cals. Some of the flavors are a little too sweet but they have a great variety on amazon

u/Butterfly_and_Bee 8h ago

I have a hard time eating enough so I tried medical marijuana to boost my appetite. I really enjoy getting high and then going to the gym and then eating a big meal. It’s awesome! This is not advice and won’t be a suitable solution for everyone. :) 

u/RC_0041 6h ago

I changed what I eat, eggs, sardines, yogurt, nuts, peanut butter, etc. Just look for protein dense food and find stuff you like.

u/One_Wrangler_257 6h ago

How do u know how much protein you need? Ive been gyming for almost a year now and only started protein powder a month ago. I dont do crazy bench or free weights. I just use the machine/non-free weights. 

u/Jokkie 6h ago

EAT NUTS. Seriously, just carrying a bag of cashews/peanuts with you to work and snacking on them can add so much calories a day. They're relatively healthy and protein rich too.

u/QualifiedApathetic 6h ago

You also need more calories. Protein supplies the building blocks for new muscle, but the process of creating that muscle also requires energy.

u/Tiny-Acanthaceae-15 5h ago

You only need 1 gram of protein per pound of "lean" body mass.

u/Tog_the_destroyer 4h ago

You need about 0.8g/lb at the upper end. You can make do with less than that

u/CSPN 5h ago edited 5h ago

you've been lied to about protein intake. realistically you only need 0.5-0.6g per lb of body weight.

the extra calories are what drive growth

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j1bx0GMofYw

u/ladiestreat 10h ago

Can’t train like a horse but eat like a bird - my mom the dietician.

u/OlaPlaysTetris 9h ago

I wish I could grab little 18 year old me and put this knowledge into his brain. I struggled for like 5 years going to the gym in high school and college to put on decent muscle. I probably weighed 140-150lbs at 6 foot by the time I left college. Since then, I’ve put on like 40 pounds of muscle all because I was finally eating as consistently as I was lifting. I’ll admit my metabolism slowing was also a huge part of that, but just eating a shit ton needed to be front of my mind at that time.

u/RVelts 8h ago

I started working out in college and had access to an all you can eat dining hall for lunch and dinner. So much chicken was consumed. They had some of the most boring and bland chicken breasts available every day in the "burger/grill" line and I would just ask for 3-4 on a plate, and I learned to really love black pepper and mustard.

u/teh_drewski 4h ago

I've been lifting for 4 years at 6ft and just congratulated myself on finally hitting 150lbs lol

u/Chreiol 10h ago

One of my regrets when I was lifting hardcore (4 days on 1 off, repeat) in my 20’s was not bulking throughout.  I got obsessed with looking lean and muscular at the expense of actual mass when I was in my prime lifting years.  Was tracking calories to a near deficit and got super shredded but in hindsight I was still “small”.

Eating enough is hard.  

u/ClassicPlankton 6h ago

Alright I've been eating a shit ton and now I'm fat but not strong, what's next.

u/wegnbealrght 5h ago

You aint putting the energy from cals in the gym too good use my brother

u/whoop-i-did-it-again 3h ago

Why is this comment so low!? All the workouts in the world won't mean much if you have bad nutritional habits. 

u/largemargesentme__- 3h ago

The eating isn't hard, but what you have to eat is.

Look, I can cook well, probably better than 90% of the people I know. I can come up with sauces and spices and techniques. I'm not just eating plain chicken breast and dry broccoli.

Still, I lose my mind just eating the kinds of foods you have to eat to get gains and stay lean. So I generally compromise by eating slightly worse but limiting meals (I do IF and just eat lunch and dinner).

u/wegnbealrght 3h ago

80% clean 20% what you want

u/largemargesentme__- 3h ago

Yeah, I still lose my mind. I just don't eat for 16 hours, then basically eat what I want. So my muscles aren't huge, but I'm 46 and still wearing the same pant size I was as a teenager. So I'm fine with the compromise.

u/SlipperyDingo13 10h ago

Greek yoghurt + protein powder mixed together is the most goated thing ever

u/xypherrz 9h ago

my issue is: despite counting to work, as I increase my intake I start seeing stomach fat grow

u/ReptAIien 8h ago

Don't eat in a large surplus. Frankly, there's some debate over whether you need a surplus at all to grow muscle, assuming adequate exercise and protein intake.

u/Safe_Fix_9579 9h ago

PREACH!!!

u/shantm79 8h ago

When my college aged son is home, our weekly grocery spend def increases 250%. Kid lifts and eats like food is running out tomorrow.

u/Isme1 7h ago

I scrolled way to far to find this comment

u/pacify-the-dead 7h ago

Protein intake is necessary, but bulking is bunk, the energy to actually build muscle is insignificant in terms of calories.

u/Mobile_Throway 4h ago

When I was at my strongest I would stop and get 2 of those giant little debris. I'd drink my preworkout then eat them about 30 minutes before my workout

u/asianwaste 3h ago

From what I was advised, it's also when you eat. Take in the protein before and right after the workout.

Before to make sure you don't damage your muscles and have energy. After to promote build up.

u/pixel_of_moral_decay 10h ago

And get your daily fiber.

Matters more than anything else.

No seriously. Get enough fiber and a lot of cravings will fall off. Making it easier to hit other goals.

Most people get way too little fiber. ~40g should be a bare minimum not aspirational.

u/Arkayb33 10h ago

cries in Adderall

u/protomor 9h ago

Gotta eat *properly